Customer Reviews for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
Item # : 24422621
Model # : 58677V
WARRANTY
5 Year
MATERIAL
Faux Leather
WEIGHT CAPACITY
275 lbs
Full Assembly Required
No Recline
Ergonomic
Price is $159.99, Regular price was $219.99, You save 27%
30-min pickup
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Over 30
Add to list
3850 reviews
Summary of reviews
The Staples Rutherford Luxura Manager Chair is praised for its comfort, reasonable price, and ease of assembly. However, some users report durability issues and discomfort after prolonged use. The chair's design is generally appreciated, but quality control problems are noted.
Summary generated by AI based on customer reviews, including incentivized reviews.
Most helpful positive review
Posted Feb 22, 2026
I can sit for hours
This chair is so comfortable. I got at work and soon after needed to get one for home. Good cushioning, high back, and comfort for work and crafting time.
VS
Most helpful critical review
Posted Mar 25, 2026
not good
I'm 6' 200 lbs. Not a good chair for that size, despite it's weight rating. The seat's too small and the seat padding is virtually non existent; the back's not tall enough; and it's flimsy. Probably I'll be putting it out by the curb because it's awful. So if you want a free chair come on by.
svly
Posted Mar 25, 2026
not good
I'm 6' 200 lbs. Not a good chair for that size, despite it's weight rating. The seat's too small and the seat padding is virtually non existent; the back's not tall enough; and it's flimsy. Probably I'll be putting it out by the curb because it's awful. So if you want a free chair come on by.
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
0up votes 0
1down votes 1
Report
RSaf
Posted Mar 12, 2026
Seat bottom failure
Purchased this chair locally and assembled it. Easy assembly and fairly comfortable (not great but ok). For the price (low $100s) it's nice looking but obviously plastic and not real leather. A few months into ownership, the seat bottom springs began to separate and started pushing up into the seat bottom. Still have a bit of cushion but it is not comfortable to sit ...
Read full review
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
steve
Posted Mar 9, 2026
Poor quality and effectively no warrenty
This chair was comfortable but after less than a year the back and arms began to loosen. Tried tightening everything accessible but a couple of months later the back failed to support. In trying to repair it I found broken brackets and that bolts had fallen out of the interior assembly. I relied on the 5 year manufacturer warranty but was told it only covered the lif...
Read full review
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
2up votes 2
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Hi Steve, Thanks for reaching out to us about this. I'm sorry to hear you're dissatisfied with your Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair. I've received your feedback and have forwarded your comments as a suggestion for future improvement.
Staples, March 11, 2026
SWD
Verified Buyer
Posted Feb 22, 2026
I can sit for hours
This chair is so comfortable. I got at work and soon after needed to get one for home. Good cushioning, high back, and comfort for work and crafting time.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Rick
Reviewed at:
Staples Business
Posted Feb 19, 2026
absolute junk
broken in a couple of months
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Vance
Posted Feb 17, 2026
Didn't last long
The chair was fine, comfortable enough to sit in all day. But within six months of purchase, the metal piece holding the arms to the seat broke, which caused the whole chair to fall apart within another two weeks. A waste of money for a chair that doesn't last 6 months!
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
C
Verified Buyer
Posted Feb 5, 2026
Defective Chair
Despite the product team's best efforts, this otherwise adequate chair possesses a slight lean starting from the seat itself. Hopefully this is a factory problem and not a design flaw. Would not recommend this chair now.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
TBK
Verified Buyer
Posted Jan 22, 2026
High Quality chair
Most comfortable chair in the store and it's reasonably priced when it's on sale. Bought one for my husband and I. Best Christmas gift ever as it's used daily. Cushion and back support is great if one has to sit any length of time. Every office needs a chair like this one.
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Michael D
Posted Jan 20, 2026
Okay until it broke
I bought this chair about 6 months ago, expecting it use it as my office chair for the foreseeable future. It was decent for a while, although it didn’t have the best form for posture and could get hot with the leather. It was a solid chair, but last week a piece holding the left arm snapped and the entire back has fallen apart as a result. I would expect a chair to h...
Read full review
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
wgs
Verified Buyer
Posted Jan 17, 2026
Very Uncomfortable
No wonder it was on sale! Very uncomfortable. Good news was it was easy to return.
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Manager Chair, Tan/Modern Gray (45609)
1up votes 1
0down votes 0
Report
Stacey B
Verified Buyer
Posted Jan 16, 2026
Plush and comfortable with good head support
Great product for the price
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Karen
Verified Buyer
Posted Jan 15, 2026
Very comfortable
Great leather
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Manager Chair, Tan/Modern Gray (45609)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Verified Buyer
Posted Dec 30, 2025
Good Service
We were wekk taken care of by Staples' staff.
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Manager Chair, Tan/Modern Gray (45609)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Davids
Verified Buyer
Posted Dec 29, 2025
RUTHERFORD LUXURA CHAIR
Moderate comfort....nothing to write home about....barely acceptable. From what there is to choose, I guess one can call it OK for the price...but certainly not a great value! Compared to chairs and prices of 5-7 years ago....kinda disappointing!
This review is for Staples Rutherford Luxura Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Black (ST45608V-CC)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Frank Sudore
Verified Buyer
Posted Dec 29, 2025
Desk Chair
Comfortable, perfect color, works well.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Linda C.
Verified Buyer
Posted Dec 27, 2025
Great looking manager’s chair at a great price.
This is a very well made, comfortable chair. I chose to assemble it myself and it was so simple to do with the clear instructions and well-marked parts. Well worth the money.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Tomas Skripkus
Verified Buyer
Posted Dec 24, 2025
Office chair for my desk
I do like this leather chair that I purchased for my writing desk.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
very poor quality
Posted Dec 19, 2025
multiple problems
Had multiple parts failures initially & they replaced chair twice. Two years later the back stayed reclined & and lever wouldn't hold it upright anymore. Came with 7 yr. warr. Staples warr. svc. said couldn't get replacement part for 4 months & could offer me a payout of 72% of original price as a coupon only usable at Staples. The website description says it doesn't ...
Read full review
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Rickety
Posted Dec 17, 2025
Arm connection finally broke
The bolt on the front of the left arm completely separated from the seat. Chair is barely a year old and used infrequently. It's unusable now.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Mt Spokane High School
Verified Buyer
Posted Dec 16, 2025
Great Deal
Thanks so much! This was a great experience.
This review is for Staples® Rutherford Ergonomic Faux Leather Swivel Manager Chair, Gray (58677V)
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report