Customer Reviews for Staples 58X Remanufactured Black High Yield Toner Cartridge Replacement for HP CF258X (STCF258X)
Item # : 24530241
Model # : STCF258X
Get quality you can rely on at a better value with Staples remanufactured printer cartridges: Staples HP 58X
- Yields up to 10,000 pages per cartridge
- Staples Brand cartridges will save you money compared to the National Brands
- 100% performance guarantee with U.S. based product support
Price is $199.19
Price per unit $0.02/Cost Per Page
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Over 30
27 reviews
Most helpful positive review
Posted Jun 24, 2024
Staples Remanufactured Black High Yield Toner Cart
A quality product that saves $ & works just like the original. I buy these all the time! Thank you Staples!!!
VS
Most helpful critical review
Posted Oct 6, 2022
Cartridge feedback
The cartridge leaked ink from the time of opening the package. Sent back for a refund.
JOCELYN M.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Jun 25, 2025
staples 58x
very messy to exchange black toner everywhere no matter how neat you try to be
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear Jocelyn M.,
Thank you for your review, we truly regret hearing that you are not completely satisfied with your cartridge. Our cartridges are remanufactured to perform to the same standard as the national brand. Please email us at [email protected] or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548 ext. 2469 so we can better assist you. Thank You.
Amanda L., June 26, 2025
Peter B.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Apr 28, 2025
staples remanufactured cartridge is a BIG NO
when ordered staples customer service told me many customers are happy with the cartridge from staples verse the brand for HP.
never have been able to get these to work in my HP printer . I am always told that the verification sticker is NOT an HP product so they never work in my printer. many calls to staples service department have proven useless, and staples even put...
never have been able to get these to work in my HP printer . I am always told that the verification sticker is NOT an HP product so they never work in my printer. many calls to staples service department have proven useless, and staples even put...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear Peter B,
Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry to hear you are not fully satisfied with your HP 58X BRAND remanufactured cartridge. This could be related to a firmware update pushed by HP to your printer. If that is the case, we would be happy to replace the cartridge with inkjets that are compatible with your printer. Please email us at [email protected] or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548 ext. 2469 so we can better assist you. Thank you!
Linda H., June 10, 2025
Kelley C.
Verified Buyer
Posted Nov 21, 2024
Does not work
This item will not work with our current printer. The printer gives an error message that says "no chip detected"
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Yvonne T.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Jul 24, 2024
Does not work with HP printer
We ordered this for our HP and we could not use this cartridge because of some type of chip.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Staples Customer
This reviewer received a free product or coupon in exchange for an unbiased review of the product
Posted Jun 24, 2024
Staples Remanufactured Black High Yield Toner Cart
A quality product that saves $ & works just like the original. I buy these all the time! Thank you Staples!!!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Kaitlyn E.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Jun 20, 2024
Leaves streaks on paper
I made it about half way through the toner cartridge, and suddenly it started leaving a streak down the right side of the paper. I took it out, cleaned the roller inside, and replaced it. It worked well for about 50 pages, and then did the same thing. I will not be buying this product again.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Staples Customer
This reviewer received a free product or coupon in exchange for an unbiased review of the product
Posted Mar 18, 2024
Chip doesn't work...
Did not work. Got 2 toners and each one did not work. The HP printer showed an error message about the memory/chip.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Staples Customer
This reviewer received a free product or coupon in exchange for an unbiased review of the product
Posted Mar 15, 2024
Staples Remanufactured Toner Cart
So far so good. While the Mfg. product indicated ~10K pages on high yield toner, the staples did not state the number pages but it does appear to be about the same. Third time using the staples brand and will continue for the savings.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Staples Customer
This reviewer received a free product or coupon in exchange for an unbiased review of the product
Posted Mar 13, 2024
Works well
Works just as well as the name brand for a lot less money! So far no problems & if something goes wrong Staples will replace it for no charge.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
MARCIA M.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Jan 18, 2024
No problems!
We have been ordering these for a couple years now and have had no problems.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear Marcia Thank you so much for your review! We value our customer's feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to contact our dedicated ink and toner support team at 1-877-228-3128.
Cindy, January 26, 2024
Response from Staples :
Dear Marcia Thank you so much for your review! We value our customer's feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to contact our dedicated ink and toner support team at 1-877-228-3128.
Cindy, January 18, 2024
Stephanie K.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Dec 19, 2023
Staples Toner Cartridges
The Staples Toner Cartridges do not work in HP printers because there is an error that comes up on the printer that says that it must have an HP chip. Please do not sell these as compatible.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear Stephanie We truly apologize you are experiencing issues. This sounds like a firmware related issue due to your printer forcing a firmware update. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product. Thank you!
Cindy, December 29, 2023
Response from Staples :
Dear Stephanie We truly apologize you are experiencing issues. This sounds like a firmware related issue due to your printer forcing a firmware update. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product. Thank you!
Cindy, December 19, 2023
Ellis B.
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Sep 19, 2023
Leaks Toner
This toner leaves excess toner on the page which then is subject to spreading
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
We truly regret hearing that you're not completely satisfied with your Staples HP 58X replacement cartridge. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product.
Cindy, November 3, 2023
Response from Staples :
Dear Ellis We truly regret hearing that you're not completely satisfied with your Staples HP 58X replacement cartridge. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product.
Linda H., September 19, 2023
Christina M. W.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Apr 19, 2023
Does not work with printers needing HP chip
This cartridge does not come with an HP compatible chip, and does not work in our HP printer. There is a sticker that comes on the cartridge saying to disable auto firmware updates on the printer, and gives a website for further instructions. Even after multiple attempts to follow instructions, still did not work. Returned for a full refund and bought an HP cartridge.
1up votes 1
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear Christina We truly apologize you are experiencing issues. This sounds like a firmware related issue due to your printer forcing a firmware update. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product. Thank you!
Cindy, November 3, 2023
Response from Staples :
Dear Christina We truly apologize you are experiencing issues. This sounds like a firmware related issue due to your printer forcing a firmware update. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product. Thank you!
Cindy, November 3, 2023
Staples Customer
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Feb 10, 2023
Black Toner
The toner leaves a thick black line, on the right side of the paper
1up votes 1
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear John We truly regret hearing that you're not completely satisfied with your Staples HP 58X replacement cartridge. Please visit our Cartridge Support site: www.cartridge-support.com for troubleshooting help or call our support team at 1-877-228-3128 and we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product.
Cindy, November 3, 2023
Staples Customer
Verified Buyer
Posted Jan 30, 2023
Time will tell
As soon as I put a new cartridge in the printer, I buy a replacement so I always have one on hand. Consequently it may be a year or more before I need to put this one in. I decided to roll the dice and trust this item will be equivalent to the OEM in every way, or that at least it won't screw up my printer.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Thank you so much for your review! We value our customer's feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to contact our dedicated ink and toner support team at 1-877-228-3128
Cindy, November 3, 2023
RAYMOND O.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Jan 24, 2023
City manager
Quick and easy ordering
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Thank you so much for your review! We value our customer's feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to contact our dedicated ink and toner support team at 1-877-228-3128
Cindy, November 3, 2023
Shawn D.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Jan 5, 2023
Staples / Red Dot Remanufactured Cartridge
We have had multiple issues with these brands. From HP printer stating Cartridge Chip does not match, too one cartridge example 30x having a sticker placed on it saying its now an 83x.
1up votes 1
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Dear Shawn We truly regret hearing that you're not completely satisfied with your Staples HP 58X replacement cartridge. Please reach out to our support team at 1-877-228-3128 so that we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product.
Linda H., January 13, 2023
Response from Staples :
Dear Shawn We truly apologize you are experiencing issues. This sounds like a firmware related issue due to your HP printer forcing a firmware update. Please reach out to our support team at 1-877-228-3128 so that we can assist you in resolving any issue you are experiencing with the product. Thank you!
Linda H., January 5, 2023
ANGELA H.
Verified Buyer
Reviewed at:
Staples Advantage
Posted Oct 6, 2022
Cartridge feedback
The cartridge leaked ink from the time of opening the package. Sent back for a refund.
3up votes 3
0down votes 0
Report