Customer Reviews for Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty, Assorted Colors (STP-ASST)
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty, Assorted Colors (STP-ASST) is In-store only
Item # : 24552294
Model # : STP-ASST
- This putty provides a relaxing yet stimulating interaction for anyone with sensory integration issues
- Recommended for ages three and up
Price is $9.99
30-min pickup
See alternate delivery items
19 reviews
Most helpful positive review
Posted Sep 25, 2025
PREETTTYY
This putty is so prettyyy and shiny with the opal-white color. The yolk is even more fun to play and squish with!! So fun
VS
Most helpful critical review
Posted Jan 11, 2026
Rip off.
I bought 3 small cans. What a waste and of money. Very little product in the can. Never again.
Lw
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Jan 11, 2026
Rip off.
I bought 3 small cans. What a waste and of money. Very little product in the can. Never again.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Matt
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Dec 26, 2025
Yolk pops easily.
Just like the other person said, the egg yolk popped within minutes of opening, and it hardly took any pressure or play for this to happen.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Alex from sweden
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Dec 12, 2025
I like it but the yolk had tears
I really like the putty, it's much firmer than i expected but fun to play with. However the yolk came with two tears and inproperly fused opening :/ I was very disappointed, hope it can be made with better quality.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
bob27
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Dec 12, 2025
Great but can be so hard to open.
I bought several different versions of this product last year and my whole family loves it but we can never get them back open. You should reach out to Container and Packaging in Eagle Idaho we could help you with some better packaging.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
washmybellay-pibble
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Sep 25, 2025
PREETTTYY
This putty is so prettyyy and shiny with the opal-white color. The yolk is even more fun to play and squish with!! So fun
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Terry
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Jul 18, 2025
Soft texture fears bursting the yolk
In comparison to other puttys this one has a very soft easy to move texture. Great for old lady hands. I am fearful of busting the yolk though. It seems unstable. I probably won't use it. Shame, it was a fun idea though.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Jasper
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Jun 28, 2025
Great putty, yolk needs work
The putty itself is great, as usual. However, the yolk broke really quickly. Like, within 2 uses quickly. And I dont play with it roughly.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Evie
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Jun 24, 2025
Amazing!!
amazing! the egg squishy is super soft and needable and the putty has a nice shine to it! would definatly buy again!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
frog
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted May 11, 2025
Yummy Yolk
I received it as a gift a few days ago. My favorite part is the soft/smooth squishiness of the yolk. Reading other reviews on here, I must have gotten lucky with the strength of the yolk. We stretched it out a lot and it still held its shape/ didn't burst (fingers crossed it never does; the yolk is my favorite part lol). The putty has a nice texture too! I like how the...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
SSW21
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Apr 23, 2025
Fragile
Yellow squishy popped after the first kid played with it and he wasn't rough with it either. It's pretty fragile.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
JuicyBird
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Apr 21, 2025
A Favorite with Two Distinct Textrues.
I love the glistening white putty- it's really shiny and beautiful, maybe my favorite. The yellow "yolk" has a different texture completely; it is squishy, bubbly, and a bit slimy - kind of so creepy that it's cool. Stress-reducing both separately and together.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
noahlovesputty11
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Apr 20, 2025
Not the Best
This Putty is okay but I find that it is hard to close and hard to play with. When you try to play with the putty and the yolk it is very difficult, When you try one at a time though it's just weird. I would recommend just buying a normal putty or a squishy ball because these two don't mix.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
SirPumpkaboo
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Apr 4, 2025
This putty is eggceptional
I really like this putty, my only complaint is that the yolk has a very small hole in it. This isn’t a problem yet, and I have been playing with it a bit rough, but it’s still bothersome. Not eggaggerating , though, this putty is all it’s cracked up to be!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Ladyjacket
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Mar 25, 2025
Yolk breaks
We bought this and the yolk burst within minutes of opening. Very disappointing!!!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
puttyfan11
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Mar 23, 2025
FUN TOY!
I bought this because it looks so cute and i love it! so fun the squishy ball is so soft an amazing.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
PuttyBunny
Reviewed at:
Crazy Aaron's
Posted Mar 20, 2025
THE BEST!!
10 out of 10!!! My favorite out of the 60 styles I own. Love the yolk ball which is incredibly fun!! Might order a 2nd one as a back-up!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
L.M.
Verified Buyer
Posted Mar 6, 2025
Slime
It was dry when we opened it. Waste of money!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Response from Staples :
Hi Lauren thanks for replying to our product review request. We appreciate you taking to time to let us know about your experience! ^BF
March 7, 2025