Customer Reviews for Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, 8 Fl. Oz. (11226)
Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, 8 Fl. Oz. (11226) is In-store only
Item # : 24593773
Model # : 11226
Neutrogena gentle oil-free liquid eye makeup remover helps to remove all eye makeup, even waterproof mascara. Non-greasy makeup removing cleanser is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
- Neutrogena 100% oil-free liquid eye makeup remover and cleanser for sensitive eyes
- 8-fluid ounce bottle of Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover
Price is $10.79
30-min pickup
See alternate delivery items
3993 reviews
Most helpful positive review
Posted Jan 31, 2026
Very good
I love this product to remove makeup from my eyes, it removes everything even the strongest masks. This bottle has a good amount, it lasts a long time. It doesn't irritate me and has no smell. It's very compatible with my skin. In the bottle come all the instructions on how to use it.
VS
Most helpful critical review
Posted Jan 6, 2026
Just say no!
Another Neutrogena makeup remover that burned and dried my skin. The alcohol-free version is no different. It hurt so much that I threw them in the garbage. The formula was not effective at removing waterproof makeup and I had to use more than one sheet to remove my waterproof mascara only to still find excess residue. Since I threw this product out, I posted another pr...
Read full review
loreleif11_5858
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Feb 2, 2026
Great, but not for sensitive skin
I do like how well the product works on your skin, as it does get the makeup out. I do feel some irritation but I also have really sensitive skin. I think it would work well for people who don’t have such sensitive skin, as it’s an oily finish and I don’t respond well to oils. Other than that it works well for what it is!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
milemontess_2201
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 31, 2026
Very good
I love this product to remove makeup from my eyes, it removes everything even the strongest masks. This bottle has a good amount, it lasts a long time. It doesn't irritate me and has no smell. It's very compatible with my skin. In the bottle come all the instructions on how to use it.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
diannem38_6329
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 26, 2026
Gentle and works on waterproof makeup
Love this eye makeup remover. I soak it on a cotton pad and hold it over my eye to break down my eyeliner and mascara and it wipes away so easily without being harsh on my eye. I love that it’s unscented and removes waterproof mascara. It’s very slippery so it won’t tug on my delicate eye area. I have really sensitive eyes that gets irritated and a lot of products burn ...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
allym212_3284
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 26, 2026
Good product
Although these are for your eyes, if you get it in your eye, it will hurt so make sure to be careful about that but otherwise it works pretty well and gets all of your makeup off. It is a strong product.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
madeleinem70_147
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 23, 2026
The best eye makeup remover
The Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover. As you can see, it's a dual-phase formula, which means you have to shake it up before you use it
The main purpose of this product is to remove stubborn waterproof makeup, and it absolutely delivers. You just soak a cotton pad, press it gently over your eye for a few seconds, and everything wipes away cleanly without harsh rub...
The main purpose of this product is to remove stubborn waterproof makeup, and it absolutely delivers. You just soak a cotton pad, press it gently over your eye for a few seconds, and everything wipes away cleanly without harsh rub...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
brittanyp300_9926
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 22, 2026
Gentle makeup remover
I really like this eye makeup remover. It removes mascara and eye makeup gently without burning or stinging my eyes which is huge for me. It feels lightweight and doesn’t leave a greasy residue even though it gets the job done. I did have to use a little extra for waterproof mascara which is why I gave it four stars instead of five.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
elenamarkin11_5306
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 21, 2026
Solid option
I used this eye makeup remover for a long time and it did a really good job removing waterproof mascara without stinging my eyes. It’s effective and easy to use, but I did notice it can leave a bit of a greasy residue, especially if you use more than needed. I eventually switched to micellar water for a lighter feel, but this is still a solid option if you want somethin...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
ksumm77_5810
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 18, 2026
Best eye makeup remover
I love this eye makeup remover. It’s gentle and effective on regular or waterproof mascara. I tried going without using this and just did facial cleanser and water. That was a big mistake because it caused drying on my eyelid. I went back to using this makeup remover and no problem with drying.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
amys1506_1488
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 15, 2026
Shake that bottle, good!
The science behind this is amazing! As long as you remember to SHAKE THE BOTTLE THOROUGHLY this eye makeup remover is incredible! Seriously though, shake the bottle thoroughly, not just a little, give it a good 6 second shake. You don't have to press hard or rub on your skin, it really does melt your makeup away effortlessly. I highly recommend if you wear eye makeup!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
lucyh353_3250
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 15, 2026
Oily and irritating
This makeup remover removes all makeup. Stubborn waterproof eye makeup, eyelash glue, everything. But I find it very irritating and oily. I started using a cleansing balm instead.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
catheyw_3321
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 14, 2026
Great for sensitive skin!
I have tried premium brands and always return to Neutrogena eye makeup remover.
The oil-free product feels clean and it works so well - even with waterproof mascara. Just shake it to mix the ingredients for the perfect concentration.
It has no scent, which is great for us sensitive skin girlies.
10/10
The oil-free product feels clean and it works so well - even with waterproof mascara. Just shake it to mix the ingredients for the perfect concentration.
It has no scent, which is great for us sensitive skin girlies.
10/10
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
gigimakeup_6496
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 12, 2026
Very gentle and nice Makeup remover for a good pri
The best makeup remover ever. I have been using this makeup remover for very long time. even removes waterproof kind of eye makeup from your face and it’s very gentle for your face never causes any irritation or any sensitivity. It’s sent less and it’s nice.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
jamieblakereviews_3384
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 9, 2026
My favorite eye makeup remover!
This is my goto eye makeup remover. I highly recommend this to everyone including this with sensitive skin. I have used for years and will continue to do so.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
yuliia14t_4200
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 9, 2026
The perfect 😍
This is by far my favorite eye makeup remover! These is no oily residue and my skin does feel soft! It cleans up my eye makeup so quickly, very effective in my product! It’s a great strength but doesn’t hurt your face! After using my face it nice and clean with a fresh appearance!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
meghanm253_6683
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 6, 2026
Just say no!
Another Neutrogena makeup remover that burned and dried my skin. The alcohol-free version is no different. It hurt so much that I threw them in the garbage. The formula was not effective at removing waterproof makeup and I had to use more than one sheet to remove my waterproof mascara only to still find excess residue. Since I threw this product out, I posted another pr...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
giermanne_5219
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Jan 1, 2026
Gentle.and effective
This product is oil free and gentle in the skin. It removes all trades of mascara without heavy pressure. It doesn't cause any red ess or irritation. I highly recommend.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
joannao62_3081
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 30, 2025
Best makeup remover
This is my 3rd repurchase and I honestly will never go back. I would always struggle to take off my waterproof mascara, but with this it takes it off at an instant. It is a bit oily so i recommended that you just use some water right after. Other than that it’s amazing
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
mohinabonui_7411
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 27, 2025
Neutrogena
This makeup remover is absolutely great working. Not too oily or not too without oily. It’s a normal texture. After the remove your make up with this makeup remover. Your face will become gently clean.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
1_l0v3ly_diam0nd_1470
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 24, 2025
Very effective eye makeup remover
This Neutrogena stuff is exactly what they named this product because of its very gentle yet highly recommended ingredients for the skin after cleansing makeup products off. This is definitely a we'll loved goodie in my cosmetics cabinet. It doesn't strip your skin at all it just basically helps breakdown stubborn makeup products for a clean and fresh face. It is really...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
robinw115_3928
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 17, 2025
Soothing aloe that calms the skin
Non greasy , affordable and suitable for eye contacts that has soothing aloe that activates stubborn makeup and liner. A great price point and it is available and has cucumber that calms the skin.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report