Customer Reviews for Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, 8 Fl. Oz. (11226)
3973 reviews
Most helpful positive review
Posted Dec 15, 2025
Gentle oil-free cleanser that cleans effectively w
Gentle, oil-free cleanser that removes makeup without irritation, leaving skin fresh, balanced, and comfortable for daily sensitive skin use.
VS
Most helpful critical review
Posted Nov 5, 2025
Not acceptable...
I will never buy another neutrogena product agaIN after purchasing the eye makeup remover. There is no seal at all on it or under the cap so not sure what is in it. Any person can open it and fill it with acid or anything and us unsuspecting customers can have life long injuries. This is just not acceptable for a huge company like Kenvue or soon to be Kimberly clark. Bu...
Read full review
jessicabrashier_4080
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 15, 2025
Gentle oil-free cleanser that cleans effectively w
Gentle, oil-free cleanser that removes makeup without irritation, leaving skin fresh, balanced, and comfortable for daily sensitive skin use.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
tienh12_763
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 12, 2025
My favorite so far!
It's gentle on sensitive skin without stinging or burning. it leaves our skin feeling moisturized without any greasiness. It’s true to the title as it’s very gentle, yet powerful and effectively cleanses my skin and even easily removes waterproof makeup. It’s super gentle, never stings, never causes irritation, and best of all, it doesn’t leave my eyes blurry like some ...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
sarahb2711_1225
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 8, 2025
Works!
I like that this doesn’t leave my face super oily. I don’t need to saturate a cotton ball, just a few dabs works to get even the toughest mascara off.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
marinay12_1732
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 7, 2025
Wonderful
I am kids entertainer and dancer, so I do a lot of different make ups, from easy one to stage makeup, like turning myself into fiona.
So I tried tones of make-up removers... for me, it works the best, doesn't hurt my skin.
So I tried tones of make-up removers... for me, it works the best, doesn't hurt my skin.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
lisam1053_8106
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Dec 5, 2025
Works really well.
This Gentle Oil-Free eye makeup remover works really well for me, especially when I use waterproof mascara. The only problem I have with it is that it leaves a very oily residue.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
torim103_4753
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 29, 2025
Worth the money
Good to clean off makeup but burns your eyes. So you need to be careful. Leaves a residue on your skin that feels oily but hydrating. Would rate a 7 out of 10
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
janicem76_6013
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 29, 2025
Product delivers
Love that it is unscented, and does a great job of removing any traces of eye makeup. My go-to for eye makeup remover. Way better than makeup wipes.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
angelicap238_9426
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 26, 2025
Best makeup remover on the market!
Initially, I bought this product on a whim, wanting to try something new and it was the
best decision I made. Constantly struggling to find a make up remover that would take off everything without the constant rubbing and repeated face washing. This one completely took off all of my waterproof mascara and make up and at a good price point. You really can’t beat it. If ...
best decision I made. Constantly struggling to find a make up remover that would take off everything without the constant rubbing and repeated face washing. This one completely took off all of my waterproof mascara and make up and at a good price point. You really can’t beat it. If ...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
sandig21_2378
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 21, 2025
It's a great product
Works great. Easy to use. Make up removes easily. Makes you skin feel smooth and soft. Pulls mascara right off and texture is silky smooth. Definitely worth giving a try!!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
cjsxcountrygirl_3530
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 18, 2025
Awesome
I really like this product! It’s very gentle on your eyes and never bothers me. It takes all eye makeup off with ease. I will continue to use this product
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
rochellereed_9615
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 16, 2025
Perfect for those with sensitive skin.
This has been my go to eye makeup remover for years! I have sensitive skin and this takes off my mascara, eyeliner and eye shadow so easily without bothering my skin.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
lyd05_3171
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 11, 2025
Works well to remove makeup
This make up remover works well and remove dirt and Makeup from your face. The packaging is convenient as I just pour it onto a cotton pad. I do prefer oil based for waterproof makeup, but this works well if your make up is not waterproof.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
isabellak159_5524
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 7, 2025
Fast and easy
Love this product! It takes my eye make up right off which is great because I use a primer and it is hard to get off with other products. This one took it off within seconds!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
yajairap22_1724
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 6, 2025
Gentle and effective
The thing that I like most about this makeup remover is that is really gentle with my eyes. The most difficult part of removing makeup for me have been the eye-mascara but this oil works pretty good. My sling is oily but I haven’t had any issues on using this
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
DKT.
Reviewed at:
neutrogena.com
Posted Nov 5, 2025
Not acceptable...
I will never buy another neutrogena product agaIN after purchasing the eye makeup remover. There is no seal at all on it or under the cap so not sure what is in it. Any person can open it and fill it with acid or anything and us unsuspecting customers can have life long injuries. This is just not acceptable for a huge company like Kenvue or soon to be Kimberly clark. Bu...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
qutipiecx_3038
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Nov 4, 2025
The Only Makeup Remover I Use!
This stuff works surprisingly well at breaking down stubborn makeup. Even with waterproof mascara, it comes off easily without needing to scrub or tug at my lashes. The formula feels gentle and doesn’t leave an oily or greasy residue on my skin. I also like that the bottle is simple to use and dispenses just the right amount of product onto a cotton pad. Overall, it’s a...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
saraashley25_9453
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Oct 31, 2025
Clean
This is my go to oil free eye makeup remover! It is quick easy and gets the job done. Other brands have tried but no comparison to neutrogena. Plus inexpensive and perfect sizes
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
mjfoster95_6285
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Oct 30, 2025
Effective
It works perfectly and goes a long way. It doesn't smell like anything to me. I didn't check the ingredients but the packaging is nice and compact.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
malloryc428_1200
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Oct 27, 2025
Effective, worth the purchase!
The packaging of this product is nice. I appreciate the clean appearance. Product seems to have gentle ingredients and works well with sensitive eyes. It doesn't have much of a scent
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
kellim481b_2946
Reviewed at:
influenster.com
Posted Oct 26, 2025
Efficient eye make up remover
This make up remover definitely takes off make up quickly, including long lasting eye, and lip makeup! Although it says oil free, I still felt like it left an oily texture to my skin after use.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report