Customer Reviews for Legendary Foods Strawberry Protein Pastry, 2.2 oz., 10/Box (10090)
Item # : 24647900
Model # : 10090
Protein pastry with amazing strawberry flavor and incredible nutrition
- Gluten-free and keto-friendly
- Net weight: 2.2 oz.
Price is $37.99
Unit of measure 10/Box
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Over 30
341 reviews
Most helpful positive review
Posted Feb 3, 2026
These are so addictive which
These are so addictive which in theory makes these beyond dangerous to eat. I've tried the chocolate and the strawberry one and I have to remind myself not to eat TWO in one sitting. Can't wait to try the other flavors. May I suggest a flavor. . raspberry?
VS
Most helpful critical review
Posted Feb 26, 2026
Sickeningly Sweet Taste
I love a strawberry toaster pastry but this was sickeningly sweet tasting. I was so excited when I saw these and couldn't wait to try them. I went into it with an open mind knowing it was likely to taste very different from other toaster pastries. Unfortunately, it had a super sweet, almost chemical taste to it. I didn't mind the density of the pastry but couldn't get p...
Read full review
Nicole
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Feb 26, 2026
Sickeningly Sweet Taste
I love a strawberry toaster pastry but this was sickeningly sweet tasting. I was so excited when I saw these and couldn't wait to try them. I went into it with an open mind knowing it was likely to taste very different from other toaster pastries. Unfortunately, it had a super sweet, almost chemical taste to it. I didn't mind the density of the pastry but couldn't get p...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Jayson
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Feb 16, 2026
Disappointed
The package does not match the product in the slightest. As soon as I bite into this the texture turns becomes oddly soft, not sure how that happens but I do not care for it.
I don't know if my product was just a bad batch but I am very disappointed. Unfortunately, not worth the money.
I don't know if my product was just a bad batch but I am very disappointed. Unfortunately, not worth the money.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Tyler D.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Feb 10, 2026
Rainbow mold
The taste is decent considering the protein, but the texture is like eating a shoe. And just look at the package versus the product you receive. This is flat out false advertising, it looks nothing like a toaster pastry. Are those supposed to be sprinkles or rainbow mold? Very disappointed.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Caroline S.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Feb 5, 2026
It’s not a bad flavor
It’s not a bad flavor but it’s not my favorite one that you guys have. I still recommend though for a nice treat in the morning after it’s zapped for 11 seconds in the microwave.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Leda B.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Feb 3, 2026
These are so addictive which
These are so addictive which in theory makes these beyond dangerous to eat. I've tried the chocolate and the strawberry one and I have to remind myself not to eat TWO in one sitting. Can't wait to try the other flavors. May I suggest a flavor. . raspberry?
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Glenn D.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Jan 28, 2026
Legendary Strawberry Pop-Tarts are elite.
Legendary Strawberry Pop-Tarts are elite. Perfect balance of sweet, fruity, and nostalgic — crispy outside, soft inside, and actually packed with flavor instead of tasting like sugar cardboard. The strawberry filling tastes real, not fake or overly syrupy, and the frosting-to-crust ratio is dialed in perfectly.
Honestly, Legendary as a brand just doesn’t miss. Their pr...
Honestly, Legendary as a brand just doesn’t miss. Their pr...
Read full review
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Tracy H.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Jan 26, 2026
This one is too die
This one is too die for! OMG! Since I've been eating this pastry, my weight has gone down by 10lbs. Love, love, love it!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Scott
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Jan 8, 2026
Shrinking Product
Love the Strawberry Protein Pastries! HOWEVER, these tasty treats have become smaller & smaller…and now skimping on the frosting (!?!). C’mon, the frosting is the best part! Nevertheless, I will continue to buy, because I’m addicted to them. 😩
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Thomas
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Jan 6, 2026
Terrible
Strawberry pop tart wannabe taste horrible. Has a plastic consistency and taste like it too. I ate one and gave it another chance. Ended up throwing the rest in the trash. Yuck 🤮
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
John D.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Jan 6, 2026
changed for the worst
Legendary has changed everything about their products. The texture is mushy now, the filling is dry and minimal. these products used to be amazing but now they are my last resort.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Alex C.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Dec 19, 2025
Dry, dense but good substitute
Good substitute but dry, dense overly sweet. Also, quality control in final product is lacking. Frosting was off center and sloppy.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Lisa M.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Dec 19, 2025
These are much smaller and
These are much smaller and distorted. Not what they were. Same good taste but something’s changed in the last few months.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Lynne W.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Dec 14, 2025
This is probably my favorite
This is probably my favorite flavor ! It actually brings me joy when I have one!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
frankwence W.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Dec 12, 2025
They are my go to
They are my go to breakfast. As a prediabetic, these are amazing and don’t spike my blood sugar. They also help me achieve my daily protein goals. I absolutely love them!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
HCM
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Nov 13, 2025
Used to be good - terrible now
These used to be good and now they're terrible. They no longer have a strawberry gooey middle but a gross, dry crumbly middle. Heating it up doesn't even save it. Used to love these and I've stopped buying them. Terrible move changing the recipe, they're gross now.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Darren
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Nov 9, 2025
The 24’ rebrand is awful
Uh oh they really made them and now they are awful. i loved these products before they redid the packaging and made them smaller and cakier! Now they are awful taste like a fake protein bar!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Rhonda M.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Nov 7, 2025
Super expensive but this is
Super expensive but this is nice for a tasty sweet treat!!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
TJ D.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Nov 4, 2025
I don’t eat protein bars
I don’t eat protein bars often anymore but these things have a chokehold on me!
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Alvaro V.
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Nov 2, 2025
Delicious snack with great macros…way
Delicious snack with great macros…way to beat eating boring foods all day.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report
Sally
Reviewed at:
EatLegendary.com
Posted Nov 2, 2025
Changed product lower quality
Used to love these, then they changed the filling and the pastry texture. Today my pastry had no filling at all. Same high price lower quality product. Will not be purchasing again.
0up votes 0
0down votes 0
Report